Electric Mopeds vs. Traditional Scooters: A City Commuter’s Guide

The Basics: Understanding Electric Mopeds and Traditional Scooters

Electric Mopeds: An electric moped is a two-wheeled vehicle powered by an electric motor and a rechargeable battery, they follow a moped-style similar to the shape of a Vespa. They are lightweight, easy to manoeuvre, and produce zero emissions during operation.

50cc equivalent Electric mopeds have a top speed of around 28 mph (45 km/h) and a range of 30-60 miles (50-100 km) per charge, depending on the model.

125cc equivalent Electric mopeds typically have a top speed of around 60 mph and a range of 40-60 miles per charge, depending on the model.

Traditional Scooters: Traditional scooters, on the other hand, are powered by internal combustion engines that run on gasoline. They are similar in size and appearance to electric mopeds but produce emissions and require more maintenance due to their fuel-based engines. Traditional scooters typically have a top speed of 30-50 mph (50-80 km/h) and can cover longer distances before refuelling, depending on the model and fuel efficiency.

Efficiency and Performance: Comparing Electric Mopeds and Traditional Scooters

Acceleration and Top Speed:

While electric mopeds generally have a lower top speed compared to traditional scooters, their instant torque from the electric motor allows them to accelerate faster. This makes electric mopeds more suitable for city use, where quick acceleration is essential for navigating through traffic.

Range and Refueling:

Traditional scooters have the advantage when it comes to range, as they can cover longer distances before needing to refuel. However, electric mopeds offer the convenience of charging at home or at public charging stations, eliminating the need for trips to the gas station. Horwin and NIU e-mopeds charge off standard wall plugs, so you can charge them anywhere, like a coffee shop for example.

Maintenance:

Electric mopeds have fewer moving parts compared to traditional scooters, resulting in lower maintenance requirements. With no need for oil changes or tune-ups, electric mopeds are easier and more affordable to maintain in the long run.

Cost Comparison: Initial Investment and Ongoing Expenses

Initial Investment:

The initial cost of an electric moped can be higher than that of a traditional scooter, especially for high-end models. However, prices for electric mopeds have been decreasing, making them more affordable for a wider range of consumers.

In the UK bikes are sold with the OZEF grant applied which often reduces the cost by as much as £500.

Fuel Costs:

Electric mopeds are significantly more cost-effective when it comes to fuel. The cost of electricity for charging is generally much lower than the cost of gasoline, resulting in considerable savings over time.

Insurance and Registration:

Insurance and registration costs can vary depending on the specific model and location. In some cases, electric mopeds may be classified differently than traditional scooters, leading to differences in insurance rates and registration requirements. Be sure to research local regulations and insurance options before making your decision.

Environmental Impact: Emissions and Sustainability

Emissions:

One of the primary advantages of electric mopeds over traditional scooters is their zero-emission operation. By using electric power instead of gasoline, electric mopeds help reduce air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, contributing to a cleaner and greener urban environment.

Sustainability:

The environmental benefits of electric mopeds extend beyond emissions. Electric mopeds can be charged using renewable energy sources like solar or wind power, further reducing their carbon footprint. Additionally, advancements in battery technology are leading to longer-lasting and more recyclable batteries, enhancing the sustainability of electric mopeds even further.

Making the Right Choice: Tips for City Commuters

1. Assess Your Commute: Consider the distance, terrain, and traffic conditions of your daily commute. If your route involves frequent stops and starts, an electric moped’s quick acceleration may be more beneficial than a traditional scooter’s higher top speed.
2. Evaluate Costs: Compare the initial investment and ongoing expenses of electric mopeds and traditional scooters, including fuel, maintenance, insurance, and registration costs. Remember to factor in potential savings from incentives or rebates for electric vehicles.
3. Test Ride: Before making a decision, take both electric mopeds and traditional scooters for test rides. This will give you a better understanding of each vehicle’s handling, performance, and comfort.
4. Check Local Regulations: Research local laws and regulations related to electric mopeds and traditional scooters, including licensing, registration, and insurance requirements. Make sure you are aware of any restrictions or incentives that may apply to your specific location.
5. Consider Charging Infrastructure: Determine the availability of public charging stations in your area and evaluate whether you have access to a charging point at home or work. This will help you assess the practicality of owning an electric moped in your city.
6. Factor in Environmental Impact: If reducing your carbon footprint and contributing to a cleaner urban environment is important to you, an electric moped may be the better choice due to its zero-emission operation and potential use of renewable energy sources for charging.

Electric vs Petrol Mopeds & Scooters – Costs

Most rough estimates put it at about 60p to charge a standard electric moped battery for a 50-mile range.

Even with petrol scooters achieving 90 – 120mpg, at £1.65 a litre a 50-mile journey would cost you over £4 to complete!

(£1.60 * 4.54 = £7.26 for 1 gallon, or £7.26 for 90 miles range, or 8p a mile)

Comparatively, to charge a NIU batteries which are around 2100Wh, will take 2.1kWh of energy to charge.

For the UK, the average price per kWh in 2022 is around 28p. To fill an electric battery is 28*2.1 = 59p, or under 1p a mile.

And if you’re commuting, you can recharge your electric moped at work for free!

Range Per Mile
£1.60 per Litre £7.26 per Gallon 90mpg £0.08 Petrol
28p per kWh 2100Wh 50 Miles £0.01 Electric

Electric vs Petrol Mopeds & Scooters – Costs

Most rough estimates put it at about 60p to charge a standard electric moped battery for a 50 mile range.

• Even with petrol scooters achieving 90 – 120mpg, at £1.65 a litre a 50 mile journey would cost you over £4 to complete!

• (£1.60 * 4.54 = £7.26 for 1 gallon, or £7.26 for 90 miles range, or 8p a mile)

• Comparatively, to charge a NIU batteries which are around 2100Wh, will take 2.1kWh of energy to charge.

• For the UK, the average price per kWh in 2022 is around 28p. To fill an electric battery is 28*2.1 = 59p, or under 1p a mile.

• And if you’re commuting, you can recharge your electric moped at work for free! 

Range Per Mile £1.60 per Litre £7.26 per Gallon 90mpg £0.08 Petrol 28p per kWh 2100Wh 50 Miles £0.01 Electric

 

Conclusion:

When it comes to city commuting, both electric mopeds and traditional scooters have their pros and cons. Electric mopeds offer quick acceleration, lower maintenance and fuel costs, and significant environmental benefits, making them an increasingly popular choice for urban dwellers. Traditional scooters, on the other hand, may have higher top speeds and longer ranges, but come with higher fuel and maintenance costs, as well as emissions that contribute to pollution.

Ultimately, the right choice for you will depend on your specific needs, preferences, and priorities. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision that best suits your city commuting needs.